In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinion pieces in The Times.

Frank Rich/The Petraeus-Crocker Show Gets the Hook

The Short Version: Even I can’t get outraged over the Iraq war anymore.

In his words: “Yet I must confess that, sitting in MoMA, I kept looking beyond the frame of Mr. Morris’s movie as well.”

Score: D (Derailed)
Rich’s writing in this column is unfocused and tentative; what he fails to acknowledge — and what would be far more interesting — is that as little as most Americans care about the war in Iraq, they care even less about newspaper columnists like Frank Rich. The story of any empire in decline can be compelling, but Rich — whose unflinchingly pompous nature is oddly reflected in the Republican assholes he loves to rant against — fails to give us much insight into his own condition (beyond the above quote). So we are left unmoved by his plight, even when we agree with his more superficial political points.

Nicholas Kristof/Extended Forecast: Bloodshed

The Short Version: Gosh, even global warming is unfair!

In his words: “Some experts believe that the damage that the West does to poor countries from carbon emissions exceeds the benefit from aid programs.”

The Score: F (Failure)
In this column, Kristof wants us to act surprised that — omg! — the consequences of global warming may disproportionately hurt those least responsible for it, as if this were an exception and not a rule throughout the entire course of civilization. It’s particularly ironic that Kristof, who has spent more than his fair share of time in war-torn countries, has not digested this most fundamental truth. In the end, embarrassing columns like this perpetuate the stereotype of the weak-minded liberal, which of course sets back the very cause he purports to support. Sad.

Maureen Dowd/Standing By His Woman

The Short Version: Let’s hope Bill brings Hillary down, because I hate both of them.

In her words: “But the dubious deals of her husband, a seven-diamond influence peddler, do provide an unsavory contrast with some of the candidate’s positions.”

The Score: B- (Basic)
Dowd’s typically gossipy critique of the Clintons is not exactly enlightening, but it does provide a bit of a safe harbor after we have already endured the disasters of Rich and Kristof this week, and for that we are somewhat grateful.


In which The Gay Recluse becomes increasingly obsessed with The George Washington Bridge.

Time and Date of photographs: April 12, 2008, 8am, 9am and 8pm.

When we woke up, you could barely see the bridge. (But it looked great in the fog!)

The sun finally broke through and everything glistened. It looked surreal.

Tonight it was clear, which may or may not be just like the trajectory of our lives.

“The George Washington Bridge over the Hudson is the most beautiful bridge in the world. Made of cables and steel beams, it gleams in the sky like a reversed arch. It is blessed. It is the only seat of grace in the disordered city. It is painted an aluminum color and, between water and sky, you see nothing but the bent cord supported by two steel towers. When your car moves up the ramp the two towers rise so high that it brings you happiness; their structure is so pure, so resolute, so regular that here, finally, steel architecture seems to laugh. The car reaches an unexpectedly wide apron; the second tower is very far away; innumerable vertical cables, gleaming against the sky, are suspended from the magisterial curve which swings down and then up. The rose-colored towers of New York appear, a vision whose harshness is mitigated by distance.”

– Le Corbusier, When the Cathedrals Were White, 1947.


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinion pieces in The Times.

Bob Herbert/Losing Our Will

The Short Version: The war in Iraq, recession, decaying infrastructure — OMG, we’re so fucked!

In his words: “It’s both tragic and embarrassing.”

Score: D- (Depressing)

Herbert is not necessarily wrong about anything he says, but he’s not right, either. The situation in the United States is far more complicated than Herbert’s simplistic analysis, which exemplifies the problem of talking about “we” as a nation, where there are still many winners — even in Herbert’s own terms — even if they are vastly outnumbered by the losers. Because we have no reason to believe that Herbert is a “loser” — at least from a class perspective — what’s really tragic and embarrassing about this column is his use of meaningless expressions such as “precious human treasure,” which sounds (and hilariously!) as if it was lifted from a gift card.

Gail Collins/The Revenge of Lacey Davenport

The Short Version: There are some really old politicians these days.

In her words: “The age question is of particular interest this year since John McCain, at 71, is going to try to break the record for oldest newly elected commander in chief.”

The Score: C+ (Constrained)
For whatever reason — like her age — Collins holds back a bit too much here to make this column worth reading. If we’re going to speak in generalities, how about this: it’s hard to say which generation is worse, the tedious, self-righteous baby boomers or their vapid, materialistic children, who will no doubt be running things soon.


In which The Gay Recluse updates his informal but rather telling quantitative analysis of Modern Love, the weekly Style Section (of The Times) column in which openly gay writers almost never appear, and even less frequently describe a romantic relationship.

This week’s piece: The Plain, Unmarked Box Arrived

Subject: A women and her husband buy a sex chair and are too terrified by their seven-year-old son to use it (Zzzzzz). For our gay (but frankly, equally boring) alternative, click here.

Filed under: Straight Woman on Relationships

The updated tally (or why we feel like animals in the zoo): 6 out of 174 columns by openly gay writers; 1 out of 174 on female gay relationships; 0 out of 174 on male gay relationships. In what is arguably the “gayest” section of The Times, more women have written about gay men than gay men have.

Outstanding question to Daniel Jones, editor of Modern Love: WTF?

Straight Woman on Relationships iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii ii (42)
Straight Woman on Family iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii (35)
Straight Woman on “Looking for Love” iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iii (33)
Straight Woman on Breaking Up iiiii iiiii iiiii iiiii iii (23)
Straight Man on Relationships iiiii iiiii i (11)
Straight Man on Breakup iiiiii (6)
Straight Woman on Gay Men iiiii i (6)
Straight Man on Family iiiii i(6)
Straight Man on “Looking for Love” iiiii (5)
Gay Man on Family ii (2)
Gay Woman on Relationship i (1)
Gay Woman on Family i (1)
Gay Man on Self-Hatred i (1)
Gay Man on Prom Date i (1)
Ambiguous/Nurse on Drugs i (1)


In which The Gay Recluse provides a gay (but frankly, equally boring) alternative to this week’s Modern Love offering in The Times. Those looking for our quantitative analysis should click here.

The Plain, Unmarked Box Arrived

By LORI JAKIELA and THE GAY RECLUSE

Published: April 13, 2008

THE night we ordered the sex chair, we’d been drinking. Not a lot, but enough to make a sex chair seem like an investment, like junk bonds or an I.R.A. (You know, in case you didn’t know what an “investment” is!)

The kids were asleep. Darla and I were at the kitchen table, recovering from our son Locklin’s seventh birthday. We’d thought we had kept it simple this year — bowling party, pizza, cake.

“We’ll go easy,” I said. “Low stress.” Even though I’m often annoyed to the point of tears about any number of things, I generally find myself incapable of projecting much beyond this kind of laid-back, easy-going attitude, which of course is totally fake. But it drives Darla nuts! “Stop being such a passive-aggressive hippie bitch!” she’ll say, but obviously on some level she likes it, too.

Last year we had a party at home. We hired two clowns, a husband-and-wife team who ran ads in the Pennysaver. They were a bargain: $200 cash for two hours, including a magic show, a live animal show, face painting and balloons. I felt lucky to find them, because I wanted to terrorize Locklin, the little shit, because he had really been getting on my nerves!

But minutes after they arrived in a rusted-out Chevy van smelling like smoke and stale beer, we gleaned the truth: the clowns—like most straight people lol!—didn’t seem to be happily married. The reason they were late, according to Mrs. Clown, was that Mr. Clown couldn’t follow directions to save his checkered backside (sad use of “backside” count = 1!). They argued in our driveway. At one point, she kicked him with her huge clown feet. They were drunk! He waved a lit cigarette close to her rubber nose and face paint. (Of course this didn’t really happen, but I saw it in a funny movie once!)

Later they let a goose and a terrier loose in our basement, made the birthday boy wear a toilet seat as a lei, fashioned a pair of balloon boobs, and set off firecrackers on our new rug. (I’m making this up too, of course!)

“I don’t care what we do this year,” Darla lied aggressively when the subject of Locklin’s birthday came up, taking a page from my passive-aggressive repertory. “Just no more clowns!”

So Lokay Lanes it was, the local bowling alley where, 10 years ago, the Farrelly brothers filmed the movie “Kingpin.” I know: like who cares!

Our party was Darla and I and 19 sugar-rushed first graders. We tried to keep them from knocking each other unconscious with bowling balls while our 3-year-old daughter, “Phelan”—don’t ask—stuffed cake into the automated ball returns. After 20 minutes, the kids realized that all the toys in their party bags — glow sticks, lollipop rings, gummy wristbands — could be used as weapons.

You would think I would have learned. Years ago, in a similar lapse of judgment, I dated this insanely butch (but hot!) woman who had been trained in Special Forces. She used to hold up things like dental floss and empty toilet paper rolls and say, “You know I could kill you with this if I wanted to.”

It didn’t help that Locklin’s party had an Army theme. The cake was shaped like a soldier in full combat gear. The boys fought over who got to eat the head. I’m not sure why I give in so easily to gender stereotypes like this—Darla and I argue about it constantly—but I think it might have something to do with being a lesbian couple in a small town: it’s almost like you want your kids to be that much more “normal” because everyone already thinks we’re freaks.

“I call brains,” one buzz-cut kid who did gang signs during the group picture kept screaming. “I call brains.”

“I feel like they’re winning,” Darla said when brains-boy stabbed her in the backside with a pink glow stick (sad use of “backside” count = 2!).

“They are,” I said, plucking icing out of my backside (awesome use of “backside” count = 1!).

Back home, we were finally alone. We had beer in frosted mugs. We had Townes Van Zandt on the stereo, a frozen pizza in the oven and a new copy of Rolling Stone. (Zzzzzz.) We sat across from one another, raised our glasses, and smiled. Darla was wearing Phelan’s lime-green monster hat, a fuzzy number with bug-eyes and devil horns. It looked like a possessed condom. OMG—a possessed condom—I’m funny!!!

Which reminds me: the sex chair. I’m getting to that.

But first, background. (Zzzzzz.) EXCUSE ME I SAID BACKGROUND!!! Lol.

This is how we spend most Saturday nights: we wear funny hats, play music that doesn’t call for hand-claps or puppets, drink cold beer and steal time while fans whir in the kids’ rooms to block out our noise. (Zzzzzz) Not that we make much. (Zzzzzz.) We keep our voices down, the music turned low. (Zzzzzz.) Locklin, the little shit, would be furious if he knew we were awake and having fun without him. Before he goes to bed every night, there are seriously annoying questions.

“So,” he says, his eyes like coin slots. Seven years old and already sure everyone is trying to get over on him. “Staying upstairs all night?”

A few years back we finished the basement and built two offices — one for Darla, one for me. One night Locklin woke up “scared” and came to find us. We were downstairs, each in our own little office. Locklin, the little shit, was incensed. Downstairs was too far away for us to save him from things like vampires and boredom. Also, he couldn’t hear what we were up to.

“Absolutely, we’ll be upstairs,” I lied, instead of just telling him to go back to bed.

“Oh yeah?” he said. “What are you going to do, young lady?” He actually speaks like this, and he’s only seven!

“Nothing much. Take a bath. Go to bed. The usual.”

“You need sleep,” he insisted, which was a strange thing to say given that we have neve imposed a single rule on him.

I noted to myself how perverse this conversation was, as if he were the parent. “I love you,” I said, timidly backing out.

“Love you, too,” he yelled, pulling the covers over his head. He pretends to snore, but I know he never goes down that easy. (Is it creepy that I talk about a seven-year old “going down?” Well, that’s the least of my problems! Lol.)

Omg I hated him! Lately, the slightest noise would set Locklin off. He would come stumbling blind down the hall, half baked from the “brownies” we had fed him but still angry. He was a tyrant and we had no control! If Darla and I wanted to have sex, we had to wait until morning, when Locklin was at school. Phelan slept late, and so we had an hour there, before work. If we wanted to have sex at night, we had to sneak, latch the bedroom door, keep the bed squeaks to a minimum, and listen for footsteps, a jiggled doorknob, the sound of small covert breathing. This is how I began to seriously hate my son.

Which is why the sex chair was doomed.

It started as a joke. Darla found the ad in Rolling Stone. There was a Web site. After a few beers, we were in the online world of Liberator. We were flirty—whatever that means—having fun, putting the day and all its small humiliations behind us. We joked about the shapes of vibrators, the seriousness of the dominatrix models, the practicality of glass dildos and six-inch stiletto boots. Then we wandered over to the furniture section.

“New waves to groove,” the front page read. “Put some funk into function.”

The furniture looked like it came from Barbie’s Country Camper — overstuffed swooshes in everything from earth tones to zebra prints. When not in use for its primary purpose, each piece converted to a chaise that promised to “cradle all the right places and recharge sexual energy.”

Darla and I had been married for over seven years. We still had sexual energy, but not for each other! So it was that word — recharge — that was so appealing. Plus the furniture looked really comfortable. And it was on sale. For just under $400, we could recharge. Revitalize. Reclaim. Ridiculous! (We were so fucking drunk.)

“What do you think?” I said.

“It’s a steal,” she said.

I dug out the credit card we usually reserved for groceries and car repairs. Darla typed in the numbers. Six days later, to our shock and regret, the Esse arrived.

It was huge. The box was plain, unmarked. We had trouble getting it through the front door. All the pictures of the Liberator furniture had shown two beautiful people sprawled in a wide-open space, a loft probably, a bachelor pad straight out of Esquire. Mod art on the walls, wood floors covered with animal skins. There was no other furniture in the shot.

“Where are we going to put it?” I asked after we finally got the Esse unpacked. We’d ordered it in navy blue. It matched the living room and our bedroom. The Esse wouldn’t fit in either.

“Downstairs?” she said. The basement, the side away from our offices, was a wide-open space. There was a fireplace. We’d painted the main room creamy beige, the same color you see in coffee shops. i.e., the worst and most bland color in the world. But at least the space was private, a whole floor down from the kids, though of course we would have to be careful. We would have to plan. This made it exciting.

“Wear thigh-highs,” Darla whispered like some stereotypical straight man while I scraped dried egg off the dishes. I made a note to dig my lingerie out from my sock drawer.

“If you go to 7-11,” I whispered as she played Mr. Potato Head with Phelan, “don’t forget batteries.”

“I’m pretty such they came with,” Darla noted.

“Really? Awesome.” I was actually getting into the idea.

But then Locklin, the little shit, came home from school, and of course went straight downstairs. Omg I hate him! He usually stayed in the living room or went to his bedroom to play with his army guys, but not this time. Who knows why. It took him a minute.

“Hey, mom,” he yelled. “Thanks for the cool chair.”

I was horrified. What a self-centered little fucker! What made him think it was his? But rather than correct him, I was too weak. Besides, the chair had lived up to the ads. It looked almost “normal.” (Hate that word, but just sayin’!) Funky, oddly shaped, but it did blend in, which is pretty much the most important thing in my life, in case it wasn’t obvious by now. (Tangent! Which word is worse: “normal” or “funky”?)

When I went downstairs, Locklin was straddling the Esse. A platoon of little plastic army guys was lined up along the curves, like an invading force on a ridge. He was holding one of the bigger army guys and making gunshot noises and yelling, “Let’s go, let’s go” and, “Look out!” and, “Aaaarrrrgh!” I so wanted to kill him!

“He thinks it’s his,” I told Darla. “It’s kinda creepy.”

“Don’t think about it,” she said. “And don’t talk about it either.”

That night, when we put the kids to bed, Phelan went right down, but Locklin did his usual anxious drill, the little shit: “Staying upstairs all night?”

“Of course,” I lied, and tried not to blink.

“O.K.,” he said, and that was it. “Good night.”

“I love you,” I said, but he already had the covers over his head.

What can I say about love after so many years of being in the same relationship? Not much!!! Sometimes it all feels like a battle, between parenthood and ourselves, between what we love and what we love and what we love. Or not. Whatever.

“Nice to see you,” Darla says on Saturday nights.

“Nice to see you,” I say, as if we haven’t seen each other in years.

I’m going to lie to you again, so brace yourself! Sometimes I wonder about Mr. and Mrs. Clown. It’s not every day two clowns throw up in your driveway — their matching rainbow wigs bobbing, smiles huge and painted on. Maybe they were just having a bad day. Maybe they’re mostly happy. Maybe when they take off their makeup and flashing suspenders, when they’re just themselves, people with real names like Bob or Alice, they say, “Nice to see you,” and fall in love all over again. Wtf am I talking about? I have no clue.

As for Darla and me, I found the thigh-highs. I lighted candles and the basement flickered like a movie set. Darla kissed me, and together we curled into the Esse’s soft, perfect curves. And then there were footsteps. Back and forth over our heads. Frantic.

“Mom?” Locklin called from the top of the stairs. “Mom?”

What can I say? For some reason I can’t stop thinking about my seven-year-old son, the little shit, when I’m about to have sex. So I stopped having sex! That’s normal, right? RIGHT!? Lol—I’m so losing my mind.

We left the chair in its place for a few weeks. Then, when Darla’s parents came for a visit, we hid it under the stairs. For some reason Darla’s parents think we’re still just “friends.”

“I don’t think they’ll know what it is,” Darla said. “But just in case.”

At first Locklin missed the chair, but now I think he has forgotten. Which is fine, because his mother and I haven’t. It’s still there, under the stairs, waiting. The Esse comes with an extended warranty. It’s solidly built, real quality stuff. An investment, made to last through almost anything. Wait, was I supposed to write about love?

Lori Jakiela is the author of the memoir “Miss New York Has Everything.”


In which The Gay Recluse documents the ruins of Washington Heights and self-referentially quotes an earlier post.

Date of photo: April 6, 2008

Location: 161st Street between Broadway and Amsterdam

This lion is understandably upset by his bad hair and tacky gold paint! (Still, he’s over 100 years old so it could definitely be worse.)

In Washington Heights we live among extremes of material decadence and breathtaking neglect, apparent in the crumbling cornices of Ft. Washington Avenue and eroding limestone facades of St. Nicholas, not to mention the tiled mosaics in the entrance foyers of the apartment palaces of upper Broadway — grand, tessellated spaces reminiscent of The Alhumbra — through which uncountable millions of apathetic feet have passed in the decades since their painstaking construction. Only here among the ruins can we permit ourselves the indulgence of a certain wistful nostalgia for the past, knowing it is one that we can never hope to regain.

–The Gay Recluse, September 2007


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinion pieces in The Times.

Paul Krugman/Health Care Horror Stories

The Short Version: Health care is a disaster! (Barrack blows, vote for Hillary!)

In his words: “You may think that this was an extreme case, but stories like this are common in America.”

Score: D (Dour)
We’re not sure who Krugman envisions as his readership, but we’re fairly confident that 98 percent of them (us) are more than familiar with how shitty (yet! expensive) health care is these days (as a rule with obvious exceptions). Nor do we think the marginal differences in the Clinton and Obama health-plan proposals justifies excoriating one at the expense of the other. Finally, Krugman would be well served to stop writing things like this: “[W]hile it’s true that hospitals will treat anyone who arrives in an emergency room with an acute problem — and it’s wonderful that they will — it’s also true that hospitals bill patients for emergency-room treatment.” (Emphasis ours.) Is it really wonderful that an emergency room will treat an emergency? Or is Krugman being sarcastic? Yikes — who knows? — get us away from this column!

David Brooks/The Great Forgetting

The Short Version: I’m very funny when I write about a “sadult” topic like memory loss! (Let me impress you with some fifty-cent words, too!)

In his words: “In the era of an aging population, memory is the new sex.”

The Score: D (Depressing)
Brooks’ periodic attempts to be funny always depress us: although we understand the humor, he never makes us laugh! Most obviously we’re sick of anything being “the new sex,” and Brooks’ anecdote about being trapped in a grocery store with an obnoxious “Proustian bully” leaves us asking why he feels so obligated to be polite, which leads to uncomfortable questions about Brooks’ ass-kissing/social-climbing tendencies.  (Call us humorless, but we also resent his simple-minded characterization of Proust.) Finally, although we’re impressed with Brooks’ ability to trot out words such as “hippocampically” and “lagniappe,” it doesn’t exactly fit the picture of one supposedly bemoaning mental failure.


In which The Gay Recluse welcomes the spring garden.

The hellebore is perhaps not the most spectacular flower, but we like it anyway: it’s a dependable friend.

We feel reassured. After months of planning, the first guests have finally arrived and they seem to be having a good time!

The hellebore is thousands of years old but decidedly unpretentious.

Imagine being this age and waking up filled with such curiosity!

Washington Heights is where they have always lived, as they are the first to admit.


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinion pieces in The Times.

Gail Collins/Pinochle Politics

The Short Version: I’m bored with politics.

In her words: “Setting aside six weeks of preparation for the Pennsylvania primary turns out to have been a little excessive.”

Score: B- (Boring)
We agree with Collins that the Democratic primary is kind of difficult to follow these days, as the candidates resort to increasingly bizarre tactics to reach voters. Unfortunately this sense of fatigue crosses into Collins’ prose here, so that we find ourselves kind of wishing it was over about halfway through.

Nicholas Kristof/Memo to Bush on Darfur

The Short Version: Here’s how to help Sudan.

In his words: “If President Bush takes all these steps, will they succeed in ending the genocide?.”

The Score: D (Depressing)
Kristof obviously knows what he’s talking about with regard to Darfur and Sudan, and we don’t doubt that his recommendations are good ones. But his prose is so earnest and pedantic that we find ourselves quickly squirming and looking out the window as we wonder wtf happened to say, congestion pricing. The problems Kristof describes are a world away, and unfortunately he never seems to succeed in bringing them any closer to home.

Roger Cohen/Asia’s Republican Leanings

The Short Version: Asian powers tend to want Republican presidents in the U.S.

In his words: “In India, the general feeling is that the Republicans are more free-trade oriented, less likely to pile on single-issue objections over outsourcing or child labor, and more ready to take a bold pro-Indian strategic approach.”

The Score: C (Cloudy)
We’re tired of Cohen’s free-trade-at-any-cost rhetoric, even if he does claim to support the Democrats.


In which The Gay Recluse documents the ruins of Washington Heights and self-referentially quotes an earlier post.

Date: April 6, 2008

Location: 161st Street between Broadway and Amsterdam

Hello, friendly lion! 100 years ago, you were not such a big deal, but now you would cost $50,000 at Olde Good Things. We’re glad you’re attached to the building; otherwise you would have been taken away when they stripped out the inside a few weeks ago!

 

Olde Good Things arrives to haul away as much treasure as they can get their hands on. So far the friendly lion hasn’t been touched! (Btw, this building sold for $500k a few months ago.)

In Washington Heights we live among extremes of material decadence and breathtaking neglect, apparent in the crumbling cornices of Ft. Washington Avenue and eroding limestone facades of St. Nicholas, not to mention the tiled mosaics in the entrance foyers of the apartment palaces of upper Broadway — grand, tessellated spaces reminiscent of The Alhumbra — through which uncountable millions of apathetic feet have passed in the decades since their painstaking construction. Only here among the ruins can we permit ourselves the indulgence of a certain wistful nostalgia for the past, knowing it is one that we can never hope to regain.

–The Gay Recluse, September 2007


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinions in The Times.

Maureen Dowd/Toil and Trouble

The Short Version: The Senate hearings on Iraq were a tragedy of Shakespearian proportions.

In her words: “You know you’re in trouble when Barbara Boxer is the voice of reason.”

Score: A (Awesome)
Great Dowd! Effective allusions to Macbeth, hilariously crushing critiques of Condi and The Maverick (and a few of the more idiotic Dems). More of this, please.


In which The Gay Recluse again laments the suffocation of the gay voice in American literature.

If you’re like us, when you scanned through the list of books included in New York Magazine‘s recent “New York City Canon 1968-2008,” you had one reaction: wtf! where are the gays? In every other format, gays are represented in numbers that are fairly typical, if not stereotypical: film (Todd Haynes); theater (pretty much everyone — “PME” — with a special feature on Tony Kushner); art (Andy Warhol and Keith Haring); television (the Robyn Bird show); architecture (Philip Johnson); classical music/dance (Franco Zeffirelli/PME); even pop music (Suicide — ? — and Magnetic Fields); there are others, of course, scattered throughout — we have listed only the most obvious.

Yet in books, the closest we get is Susan Sontag, who while perhaps one of the more brilliant thinkers of the dark ages post-war era must also be remembered as one of the hugest closet cases ever. (So may she rot in hell — kidding!) On the “literature” side of the equation, the list is filled with the usual suspects: Norman Mailer, Bernard Malamud, Don Delillo, E. L. Doctorow, Philip Roth (Zzzzzz), Jay McInerney, Michael Chabon and other straight guys (Zzzzzz) who while possibly “gay-friendly” (in the case of Chabon) are as a rule assholes ambivalent at best about the gay story, and in any case cannot be said to have ever written in a gay voice. The most tedious of these authors ignore the question entirely, which does admittedly have the benefit of ensuring a quick burial of their works in the sands of time.

But! Where is Andrew Holleran? Where is Dancer from the Dance, the one book that more than any other describes the beautiful, urban (and devastating) decadence of the 1970s and miraculously (if unconsciously) foreshadows the greatest and most compelling tragedy of New York City in the last forty years, namely the death of 100,000+ (mostly gay men) from AIDS? Or if not Holleran, where is Edmund White? Or Michael Cunningham? Or David Leavitt? (or David Sedaris!) Or Rick Whitaker? Or Sarah Schulman? Or anyone else who has written about New York City through a gay lens (which to be included in “the canon” should at least tacitly address AIDS, in the same way any serious work of literature these days must somehow acknowledge 9/11)?

While the lack of diversity in this list (meant to represent what is arguably the gayest city in the world) begs the question of what was blinding the editors (or critic Sam Anderson, who wrote the piece), our point here is not to lambaste New York Magazine; particularly when — ironically enough — in the same issue they feature a very compelling article about Ramon Torres, a once-renowned AIDS doctor who is now basically a homeless crystal-meth addict (and HIV-positive). Rather, we lay the larger portion of the blame on the publishing industry — and of course, the cultural tendencies it reflects — for the continuing suffocation of the gay voice in American literature, just as we did last fall in response to several articles in The Times.

Perhaps we were too earnest to be taken entirely seriously when we first said it, but nothing in the intervening months (and we have read a fair number of books) has changed our fundamental opinion that we are living in an seriously wounded and diseased era in which we have barely begun to acknowledge the traumatic impact of what we (as a culture!) endured as a result of AIDS (and still do!). That this is reflected in lists of books such as the New York Magazine Canon is obvious; like so many others we have seen, it perpetuates distortions and ignorance; if you read it, we encourage you to so do with a rueful laugh and a bitter smile at the sad impulses on display.

The truth is in our hands: we, too, have a history of oppression and a corresponding literary tradition that should be included in lists of the New York City Canon! We already have our Toni Morrison, and his name is Andrew Holleran! To fight for our civil rights is one thing, but it is equally if not more important to fight for our literary voice in a culture that belongs to us as much as anyone else; our stories are here within us, we shouldn’t have to beg to have them recognized, or apologize to have them told.

–The Gay Recluse, November 2007


In which The Gay Recluse is graced by our most cantankerous correspondent, The Blind Architect.

Today, in response to our recent post on shipwrecks in Washington Heights, we received the following report from The Blind Architect:

[A]s usual, any noteworthy thing you can find in Washington Heights has already been done to death in the real Manhattan a few miles to the south. As a young man, before I lost my vision in a [redacted], I snapped this shot of the cruise liner Normandie (rechristened the USS Lafayette during WW2) lying capsized in the Hudson River piers in the mid-40’s (that’s streets, not years).

 

That is a pretty big shipwreck! (We like the cars, too, and the lack of a traffic jam; this must have been a thousand years ago, during an age of “congestion pricing”?)

Thanks for that expectedly cantankerous report, TBA! We won’t defend Washington Heights except to say that it continues to be a land of shipwrecks (albeit small and insignificant ones), in both literal and metaphorical senses of the word, without regard to the vagueries of the downtown shipwreck scene that you are obviously so well acquainted with. That said, we appreciate your candor and lookforward to hearing more soon!


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinions in The Times.

Bob Herbert/A Different Kind of Election

The Short Version: Even racist Democrats might vote for Obama given how much they hate Bush!

In his words: “The table is set for the Democrats.”

Score: B- (Basic)
Nothing here to disagree with, but nothing you haven’t heard a zillion times already.

David Brooks/A Network of Truces

The Short Version: The surge is really great!

In his words: “That will mean drawing down U.S. troops at a slow pace, continuing the local reconstruction efforts, supporting local elections and reaching an informal agreement with Iran and the Saudis to reduce outside interference.”

The Score: D (Disingenuous)
Brooks paints a rosy picture of what’s happening in Iraq right now. Although we agree with his assessment of the misguided “founding fatherism” that got us into the war, we would like him to apply a similarly skeptical lens to the new narrative being fashioned, one that has much less to do with Iraq than to make The Maverick look good heading into the general election.   


In which The Gay Recluse has a bad day and indulges in a lil rant.

Here’s a shot of one seriously fucking annoying thing some people do on the subway, i.e., leave their shopping bags on the seat next to them when the entire train is filled with passengers. Most days we would just tell the guy to fuck off and move his bag, but today we were too tired and annoyed to bother and so just filmed him being an inconsiderate asshole stood there.

Hey Mister, you’re taking up two seats, but we don’t mind standing! Your little orange shopping bag? He looks really tired…he obviously deserves a seat of his own! (It’s also cute that you’re talking to him!)

add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank


In which The Gay Recluse ponders random acts of beauty garbage.

So yesterday we wrote about a giant-tote-bag-and-broken-sawhorse installation on 35th Street between 5th and 6th Avenues. Today we are happy to report that not only has the installation survived, but that it has grown!

This is facing west. We like the way the new and more chic cardboard box on the left is juxtaposed with the more tattered version on the right.

On this side, looking east, we see a more traditional arrangement, which effectively alludes to a garbage heap while transcending the form, particularly in the context of the passing midtown pedestrians.

But that’s not all! For some, the installation has taken on even greater meaning. A “humble reader” sent in the below images with the following note:

In the name of [Redacted], this must NOT be moved!!!

Umm, ok, humble reader. Let’s see what’s going on here:

Woah Nellie! Why didn’t we see that?

[Redacted] fucking [Redacted]! A miracle on 35th Street!

Thanks for sending that in, Humble Reader. We wish we could tell you that this holy relic will be preserved, but it may be out of our hands! Stay tuned for more.
add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinions in The Times.

Paul Krugman/Grains Gone Wild

The Short Version: Add soaring costs of food to the list of ways in which we are completely fucked.

In his words: “Oh, and in case you’re wondering: all the remaining presidential contenders are terrible on this issue.”

Score: D+ (Doomy)
Although we appreciate Krugman’s doom-and-gloom outlook, we remember twenty years ago when the Krugmans of the world were already predicting the end of civilization for many of the same reasons we see today. And it’s not that we don’t believe Krugman — or more to the point, that we don’t support “sustainable growth,” because we do — but we wish that he would write with some awareness of what has already not come to pass, to better preempt the boy-who-cried-wolf criticism that has already marginalized him.

William Kristol/The Shape of the Race To Come

The Short Version: In Obama versus the Maverick, McCain will win because he’s 1) a better debater, 2) he’s out of touch with the middle class.

In his words: “But a surprising number of Democrats with whom I’ve spoken expect a McCain victory.”

The Score: F (Fake)
This column is worth reading because it gives you some insight into what Obama will face in a general election; i.e., he will be painted as a muslim, n-word, “liberal,” as if that’s the worst thing in the world and not exactly what “the middle class” needs after being complelety eviscerated by Nixon and Company for the last 40 years.

Roger Cohen/A Passage to Tibet

The Short Version: Tibet is testing the limits of Chinese autocratic rule.

In her words: “But the Chinese authorities need to face some greater truths.”

The Score: B (Better)
This column hints at an interesting psychological truth, which is that those in power will inevitably sow the seeds of their own downfall. As much as we can say this about the United States, it is no less the case in China.
add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank


In which The Gay Recluse admires random acts of beauty garbage.

If you’re like us, you’ve long wondered what would happen if you took the world’s largest (and Con Edison branded!) tote, propped it open with a broken sawhorse and left it for a week on 35th Street and 5th Avenue. Would anyone move it? Or like all totes, would it just slowly fill up with the assorted detritus of urban life?

Incredibly enough, this scenario has finally transcended the hypothetical! After blithely walking around the thing for any number of days in our morning stupor, on Friday we were finally like: “Have our prayers been answered? Is that a giant Con Edison tote and broken sawhorse in the middle of the sidewalk on 35th Street?”

Fuck yes! Check it out:

Oddly but coincidentally, we’ve been thinking about selling these giant totes, except branded with “The Gay Recluse.” (Never again be embarrassed by a small tote!)

Obviously this took some time to fill up.

We’re kind of hoping it’s still there tomorrow. (And what’s that guy on the left doing with a bat?)

add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank


In which The Gay Recluse photographs shipwrecks lining the Hudson north of the George Washington Bridge.

Time and date of photographs: March 30, 2008 (afternoon)

As usual, there were those who did not survive the winter.

We tend to look at the wreckage with some disdain: “That could never happen to us!”

Yet! There is a mythological allure to the rocks, and some of this must be attributed to the promise of annihilation.

And is it so illogical when we are surrounded by such disasters?

And when there is more than some beauty to be found in the wreckage?

True: we are undoubtedly alone (and those who pretend otherwise always embarrass themselves).

One consolation: we are surely not the first (or last) to feel this way.

Those arriving in Washington Heights for the first time are often surprised to hear splintering, cracking sounds in the distance, sounds which like breaking bones or the felling of ancient trees barely need to be identified to be recognized. “Oh yes,” we nod impassively, but then feel compelled to elaborate. “The shoreline is rocky and treacherous for those unfamiliar with its jagged contours, and what you hear is the slow wreckage of some poor soul who has strayed too close, perhaps after being caught in the terrible riptide of the Hudson. Such reminders of our fate — though you are right to presume that some are more literal than others — are pervasive in Washington Heights; to live here you must learn to appreciate this fundamental truth.”

–The Gay Recluse, September 2007

add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank


In which The Gay Recluse scores selected opinion pieces in The Times.

Frank Rich/Tet Happened, and No One Cared

The Short Version: McCain is a big fucking idiot.

In his words: “The sum total of his public record suggests that he could well prolong the war for another century — not because he’s the crazed militarist portrayed by Democrats, but through sheer inertia, bad judgment and blundering.”

Score: A- (Aggressive)
Classic Rich here, telling it like it is.

Nicholas Kristof/Our Racist, Sexist Selves

The Short Version: Omg! Stereotypes exist, even for me–I’m a racist!!! (How awesome is that?)

In his words: “Yet racism may also be easier to override than sexism.”

The Score: F (Foolish)
Kristof loves nothing more than to perpetuate the stereotypes he pretends to castigate. The reality that we are all impacted by racial and sexist stereotypes is something most third graders could describe more compellingly than Kristof; nor, obviously, do we need to spend $millions “proving” it scientifically. Moreover, to be impacted by stereotypes does not necessarily make one a “racist”; ultimately it boils down to individual attitudes and daily encounters, i.e., the sort of thing that Kristof and his equally idiotic PhD friends will never be able to quantify. (And oh yeah, did anyone else note that Kristof left “homophobic” off the list? Big surprise that is.)

Maureen Dowd/The Vodka Chronicles

The Short Version: Wtf? Why does McCain try to deny that he likes to drink more than a little?

In her words: “If his campaign is bowdlerizing, let’s hope it stops before he’s a bland McNice.”

The Score: C (Cautious)
This column starts off well enough, but quickly meanders into Obama’s cigarette habit and then Bill Clinton hatred (Zzzzzz).

add to del.icio.usDigg itStumble It!Add to Blinkslistadd to furladd to ma.gnoliaadd to simpyseed the vineTailRank